Best Electric Fireplace Reviews of 2019

Looking to get an electric fireplace?

They can be a great addition to your living space.

Check out our top 10 picks and get an upgrade that suits your style.

Summary

The Touchstone 80001 – Onyx Electric Fireplace stood out from the pack thanks to its modern and elegant aesthetics. It’s also the largest unit we could find that you can mount on the wall with ease. In case you need a pocket-friendly option, we found that the BestMassage Electric Fireplace balances value and convenience well.

Electric Fireplace Reviews of 2019

Touchstone 80001 Onyx – Best Overall

best electric fireplace

The Touchstone 80001 is made to appeal to the minimalists. It comes in a stylish modern look that is sure to catch the eyes of your guests as they walk into the room.

Designed for on wall mounting, this unit is lightweight enough to be hung by one person with the help of the instructions included in the package.

You can expect this electric fireplace to comfortably heat up a 400 square room for countless amounts of hours. The fact that you can set up the flames without actually heating up the room is a great feature especially if you want to set up a romantic mood.

The Touchstone 80001is an elegant home décor that adds a touch of class to your living room especially with its realistic display. Furthermore, the installation process is straight forward thanks to the instructions that are included in the package.

Flaws but not deal breakers

The only flaw that might be an issue for some buyers is that it does not come with a thermostat. However, the two heat settings do a great job of giving you control of the room temperature while using it.

Pros

  • Safe and efficient design
  • Elegant modern look
  • Easy installation
  • Realistic fire display

Cons

  • Does not come with a thermostat
  • It might take a while to heat up the room

Best Choice Products VD-51075WH Embedded Fireplace– Runner’s up

Best Choice Products VD-51075WH

The Best Choice Products VD-51075WH is a CSA certified electric fireplace that will warm up your home just as a real fire would.

It’s an insert style fireplace that is designed for a hard-wired installation. You can operate the unit from a distance with remote control plus the brightness of the flame is easily adjustable to fit any look.

For even distribution of the heat, the Best Choice Products VD-51075WH comes with a set of internal fans that blow out the heat to quickly heat up the entire room.

Performance wise, the Best Choice Products VD-51075WH is a must-have for those seeking the ultimate comfort. You can pretty much adjust the brightness of its flame or even crank up the heat during winter all from the comfort of your sofa.

Flaws but not deal breakers

Although the Best Choice Products VD-51075WH requires no assembly you will need to know your way around installing it into your wall or an existing fireplace. This task will consume some time. Also, some users have complained that its flame was not as realistic as they expected. However, the Best Choice Products VD-51075WH offers a great deal for its price.

Pros

  • It is CSA certified
  • Designed for safety with a cut-off device
  • No assembly required
  • Easy to control with the remote

Cons

  • Installation might take some time
  • The flame display is not realistic enough for some users

BestMassage Electric Fireplace– Best value for money

BestMassage Electric Fireplace

While it does not burn with real logs or produce that beautiful scent of burning wood, the BestMassage offers all the comfort you can get form a fully-hand crafter heating machine.

It comes in a clean stylish modern look that will easily complement any living room. Made for easy wall mounting, it features a high-quality tempered glass that is tough and hard to break for durability.

In terms of safety, It is safe for both pets and children thanks to the LED bulbs that are cool to tough. In fact, when it’s in use, this electric heater remains cool. However, you should keep combustibles like fabric or paper away from the hot surfaces.

Nothing beats the comfort of a warm cozy living room. Well, this electric heater can give you that and more. It less energy it is able to heat up your entire room while being safe even when the kids are around it. It also comes with a safety shut-off that should give you peace of mind if you ever leave it running.

Flaws but not deal breakers

In addition to its capacity for safety and performance, It also comes with the convenience of remote control. Also, the 3D flames present a spectacular display that will transform any living room. However even though the installation is supposed to be easy, the package does not come with a mounting kit. This is however easy to solve as there are a ton cheap of mounting kits that you can use with it.

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Comes with a  couple of safety features
  • Uses energy efficiently
  • Beautiful aesthetics

Cons

  • There is no mounting kit in the package
  • Slight humming noise but easily bearable

Walker Edison Jackson Collection W48FPCRBW– Best Freestanding option

Walker Edison Jackson Collection W48FPCRBW

The Walker Edison Jackson Collection W48FPCRBW is so life such that you would be forgiven to think it was an actual fireplace with burning logs.

It measures 32’’H by 48’’W and a 20’’D for an elegant design fit for the corner of your living room.  Frankly, this electric heater is the best you can find if you need an electric heater that can also accommodate your TV. Made with high-grade parts, the Walker Edison Jackson Collection W48FPCRBW might require some assembly but if you follow the instruction you can be sure to get it right.

Apart from its capacity to heat up the room, It adds a nice aesthetic touch to the ambiance of any living room. However, the Walker Edison Jackson Collection W48FPCRBW does not include a thermostat. Plus assembly might take some time and there is no remote control.

Flaws but not deal breakers

Granted, this option falls slightly on the pricier side. For that, you get a pretty decent electric fireplace that is durable. And can be used as a TV stand console as well. It also features double doors for storage making it a decent addition to the furniture in your leaving room

Pros

  • Can accommodate most TVs
  • Stylish design
  • Realistic Flame
  • Easy to use

Cons

  • Does not come with a remote control
  • Assembly might take some time

Dimplex DFI2310 – Best pick with a thermostat

Dimplex DFI2310 Electric Fireplace

There are a few fireplace inserts that can beat the display of the Dimplex DFI2310.

It will amaze with just how evenly it is able to heat up your room it does this with the help of a built-in fan that forces heat to spread evenly. It does all this while remaining really quiet.

Apart from that, it’s also pretty easy to install especially if you already have an existing fireplace opening.  What’s more, is that you can control its display as well as the heater with a remote control which is great. It also comes with thermostat control that enables you to adjust it to your liking.

Basically, if you are looking for an electric fireplace that will warm up your living room while proving a beautiful ambiance, going with Dimplex DFI2310 can be a great idea. It is designed with a LED technology not to mention a display of gently glowing embers that will set the ambiance of your room instantly.

Flaws but not deal breakers

The Dimplex DFI2310 reminds most homeowners that its time to ditch the regular fireplace and switch to a much more efficient and elegant electric fireplace. Despite all the amazing features that come with this unit, it is not cheap. However, it is worth the money considering the level of convenience it brings.

Pros

  • Comes with a thermostat
  • Features a remote control for convenience
  • Realistic Flame
  • Easy to install

Cons

  • It’s a bit pricey but worth it
  • Some users complain about slight humming sound

Duraflame DFS-550-21-BLK Maxwell Electric Stove– Best option with a metallic build

Duraflame DFS-550-21-BLK

The Duraflame DFS-550-21-BLK Maxwell Electric Stove is practically indistinguishable from a real flame. It comes with a capacity to provide supplemental heating for a room as large as 400 square feet which is more than enough for most users.

The flames on the Duraflame DFS-550-21-BLK Maxwell Electric Stove are as realistic as it gets. This unit boasts of a dashing display of embers and logs burning plus you can use it without the heat.

In terms of safety, the Duraflame DFS-550-21-BLK Maxwell Electric Stove is made to be safe for kids and pets thanks to the fact that it stays cools to the touch even while the heater is on. Pus the overheat protection does a decent job of shutting off the heater before it overheats.

Flaws but not deal breakers

The unit is a must have for those who need a year-round ambiance for their home. The glowing logs on this unit provide an amazing display without increasing your electricity bill. However, some of its flaws include the fact that it comes with a short cord. The manufacturer recommends against the use of an extension. Therefore the best way around it is to put it near a power outlet.

Pros

  • Features a realistic flame
  • Comes with an overheating protection
  • It can heat up a 400 square feet room
  • Durable metallic build quality

Cons

  • The power cord is  slightly short
  • Some users complain about the noise

PuraFlame Alice 40″ Recessed– Best for color changing flames

PuraFlame Alice 40

PuraFlame is known for making elegantly designed products that transform the ambiance of your home and the PuraFlame Alice 40″ Recessed is not an exception.

To begin with, It is made with an ultra high intensity LED display that mimics a real flame for the most realistic flame effect you have ever seen.  The LED lights can be as bright as you need them to be plus you also get to either set it to crystal stones or log set.

What’s more is that the PuraFlame Alice 40″ Recessed also comes with the convenience of remote control that puts the timer, flame, and temperature setting at your fingertips.

This unit makes up a decent option for creating a relaxing and warm ambiance in your living room. it comes equips with a high capacity heater that is capable of heating up a 400 square foot room with ease.

Flaws but not deal breakers

The PuraFlame Alice 40″ Recessed is not cheap. However, all the conveniences of this electric fireplace are definitely worth the money.

Pros

  • It can heat up a 400 square foot room
  • Comes with 4 different flame settings
  • Installation is easy
  • Realistic Flame

Cons

  • Expensive but worth it
  • Remote is slightly small for those with larger hands

Ameriwood Home Chicago Fireplace TV Stand– Best option with a TV stand

Ameriwood Home Chicago Fireplace TV Stand

The Ameriwood Home Chicago Fireplace TV Stand serves three purposes to capacity. You can use it a stand for your TV, for storage as well as an electric fireplace.

This unit features an 18-inch plug-and-plays fireplace insert that uses LED lights to create a realistic flame display. All the parts combined, the Ameriwood Home Chicago Fireplace TV Stand adds a perfect ambiance to any room, especially with its overall black wood grain finish.

It that comes with this unit is capable of heating up a 400 square foot room with ease. You also get a decent amount of storage for your cable box making this the ultimate modern décor for a family.

Flaws but not deal breakers

If reports from other users are anything to go by, this unit requires assembly that might take some time. In fact, the manufacturer recommends that the assembly be done by two adults. However, if you have time, this should not be a problem.

Pros

  • Features a TV console
  • Ample storage available
  • Easy to install once assembled
  • It has a realistic flame

Cons

  • Assembly might take some time
  • Leans slightly on the pricier side

XtremepowerUS  Recessed Electric Insert Fireplace– Best realistic flames

XtremepowerUS  Recessed Electric Insert

If you are going for a modern stylish look, you have to check out the XtremepowerUS Recessed Electric Insert Fireplace.

This is a CSA certified unit that unit made by a company that prioritizes the safety of its customers.  With two heat setting ( a high and low settings) the XtremepowerUS Recessed Electric Insert Fireplace presents the perfect option to have during winter.   You can also adjust the heat levels to fit your preferences and you use the remote control to further customize the settings from your sofa.

The most outstanding feature about the XtremepowerUS Recessed Electric Insert Fireplace is the fact that it provides whisper quiet heating. Most electric fireplace units struggle to stay quiet but not the XtremepowerUS Recessed Electric Insert Fireplace. This unit comes in three sizes to choose from and with its realistic flame, you can change the ambiance of the room to fit any colour you like.

Flaws but not deal breakers

There are few flaws with the XtremepowerUS  Recessed Electric Insert Fireplace. Most user s report that it works as advertised. However, some complain that the control on the remote was a bit awkward.

Pros

  • Impressive realistic flame
  • Comes with safety overheat protection feature
  • Sleek modern look
  • CSA certified

Cons

  • The remote might need some getting used to
  • Installation might take some time

JAMFLY Wood – Best wooden design

JAMFLY Wood Electric Fireplace

For an electric fireplace that combines a sleek classic look with a modern elegant design, you should look into the JAMFLY Wood.

It is made with a stylish wood finish that comes from high-density Birch wood making it the ultimate unit for complementing your home décor.

With a capacity for energy efficiency, the JAMFLY Wood brings about a touch of innovation thanks to its ETL certified LED technology. The actual fireplace is insulated by the glass and the flame and embers do the job as expected to deliver a believable picture of logs burning.

Whether your goal is to keep warm over the winter or to add a touch of class and aesthetics to your living room, the JAMFLY Wood does a great job to fulfill that and more. It comes with a 1-year warranty which is a must-have for peace of mind. Also, it boasts of a capacity of heading up a room as large as 400 square foot which is amazing.

Flaws but not deal breakers

If you are on a budget, you might want to dig deeper into your pockets. By far, this unit is worth the money especially if you are looking for a blend of class and convenience.

Pros

  • Stylish woody finish
  • It can heat up a 400sq.ft room
  • Features a realistic log flame
  • Energy efficient design

Cons

  • Does not come with a remote control
  • There is no thermostat

Buyers guide: what to look for in an electric fireplace?

Considering the most important features in an electric fireplace is important. Here are the top most important features to keep in mind while shopping for an electric fireplace.

1. Overall aesthetics (style)

With so many electric fireplaces out there, you can be spoilt for choice when choosing one that fits your style. From rustic wall mounted units to sleek modern and stylish fireplace heaters, the options are endless.  Obviously, this depends on your own taste. However, an important thing to keep in mind is how the electric fireplace will fit in the room.

2. Heating capacity

After you have checked to confirm that the style of the electric fireplace fits your specific needs next thing is the heating capacity. Keep in mind that they are not designed to be the primary heater to your room.

They are only good for supplementary heat in your home. If you want to use your electric fireplace heater as the main source of heat, be sure to check the manufacturer’s recommendations and also check the maximum square feet that the heater can handle.

3. Safety

When you install them wrongly or operate without care, electric fireplaces can cause house fires. That is why you need to go with a model that has safety features such as overheating protection .if your electric fireplace is able to automatically shut off when it overheats, you can be sure of safety from house fires. Also, keep the fabric and other flammable material away from your electric fireplace.


Conclusion

Apart from providing supplementary heat to the room, electric fireplaces provide an aesthetic appeal without the hustle of an actual fireplace.  After researching all the ten listed products, we found that the Best Choice Products VD-51075WH Embedded Fireplace provides the best solution for an insert style fireplace. Even though the installation process might be a bit complete, this unit provides the safety that is required for an insert fireplace.

In case you are our looking for a budget option that does not compromise on quality, the BestMassage fireplace might be a good fit. It features a beautiful aesthetics yet its easy to mount and it comes with a bunch of safety features as well.

You can also check out our top pick, i.e. the Touchstone 80001. This unit sits at the Goldilocks of both price and functionality. It has versatile uses and boasts of a realistic flame.

Leave a Comment